“Homeopathic Medicine”

[BPSDB]Analysis of more factoids from Louise Mclean’s “50 Facts About Homeopathy” . This time I’m going to look at the second section, “Homeopathic Medicines”.

Fact 12 is an observation that homeopathic remedies are cheap. This is perhaps not surprising; the manufacturing process consists of dilutions, shaking and banging the container of solution against a leather covered board. These days this process is done by machine. Drops of the final solution are placed on cheap placebo pills (usually made from lactose) and allowed to evaporate. No expensive ingredients or complex manufacturing processes.

Fact 13 is an observation that pharmaceutical medicines are expensive. If I may be pedantic here, that is a fact about Big Pharma not Big Quacka. I am no great fan of the pharmaceutical giants but it has to be admitted that research and development costs have to be paid for. Even when producing generic out of patent products, the manufacturer has undertake a complex process ensuring that each pill contains a precise amount of the drug and that by-products of the manufacturing process do not find their way into the pills. Requires good quality instrumentation and people skilled enough to know how to use it. This costs.

In Fact 14 she tells us that there are more than 4,000 homeopathic medicines. All, due to the serial dilutions involved in the manufacturing process, chemically identical to the extent that – as a homeopath told a Parliamentary Committee – the only way to tell them apart is to read the lable.

Fact 15 informs us that homeopathic medicines have no toxic side effects. Unless, I presume, you are lactose-intolerant. The reality is that the general lack of side effects is hardly surprising when you consider that homeopathic remedies contain no active ingredients. They have no effects at all.

Fact 16 tells us of the non-addictive nature of homeopathic medicines. Since they have no effect on the body’s biochemistry, no cravings can be established.

In Fact 17 we are informed that true homeopathic medicine is made from one substance only. The mother tincture may contain that one ingredient but the process of dilution ensures that all of the ingredient ends up down the drain. She then claims that we are rarely informed of the ingredients of modern pharmaceuticals. Well let’s see. According to the box, my allergy relief tablets each contain 8 mg of acrivastine and 60mg of pseudophedrine hydrochloride in lactose. My supermarket own brand painkillers, according to the box, contain 200mg of ibuprofen in sucrose and also contain microcrystalline cellulose and E171. Everything else in the medicine cabinet is similarly informative. Perhaps me and the missus are lucky and just happen only ever to get medicines produced by companies who do list ingredients. Or perhaps Ms Mclean is spouting rubbish.

Fact 18 brings us to the bane of homeopathy: Avogadro’s Constant. Mclean says that any remedy up to 12C (24X or 1 part remedy to 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 parts water) potency still contains molecules of the substance and this, she misinforms us, is known as Avogadro’s number. In fact, Avogadro’s number is the number of molecules present in one gramme-molecule of the substance and is approximately 6 x 10 to the twentythird power, or 6 followed by 23 zeroes. One gramme-molecule is the molecular mass in grammes of the substance so 32 grammes of oxygen (which has a relative molecular mass of 32), for example, contains 6 x 10^23 oxygen molecules. It is true that ‘potencies’ beyond 24X are increasingly unlikely to contain a single molecule of the substance which is why conventional doctors and scientist cannot take such notions as 60X dilutions seriously.

In Fact 19 we meet the homeopathic conceit that their medicines are individualised as “every patient is unique”. Since, we are informed in Fact 14, there are 4,000+ homeopathic remedies, Fact 19 could only be true if there are fewer than 5,000 people in existence.

In Fact 20 she claims homeopathy treats genetic illness. This is a WTF moment in itself but then she claims tuberculosis, syphilis, gonorrhoea, scabies, cancer and leprosy are genetic. There may well be some genetic contribution to cancer but TB and clap for a start are are caused by bacteria.

In Fact 21 she claims that epidemics such as cholera and typhoid were treated successfully using homeopathy in the 19th century and ‘proves’ it by linking to whale.to. Scopie’s Law is hereby invoked.

In Fact 22 she informs us that there are thousands of homeopathic books available at specialist outlets. This may be true but it does not prove anything as to the efficacy of homeopathic nostrums. There are thousands of books on Black Magic available at specialist outlets too. This does not mean that someone claiming he can summon Satan is not a liar.

Well, that appears to wrap it up for homeopathic medicine. In the next exciting episode:- Homeopathic Hospitals.

Tags: , ,

9 Responses to ““Homeopathic Medicine””

  1. Zeno Says:

    I just love this! Well done.

  2. Dr*T Says:

    INdeed – good fun.

    Here is a link for Scopie’s Law


  3. Mojo Says:

    “In Fact 21 she claims that epidemics such as cholera and typhoid were treated successfully using homeopathy in the 19th century”

    For some reason it doesn’t work so well these days.

  4. Nash Says:

    “In Fact 21 she claims that epidemics such as cholera and typhoid were treated successfully using homeopathy in the 19th century”

    I’m currently researching the claims for the 1853/54 Cholera epidemic in London. The Royal Hoe hospital has no records and other records seem to be as non-existent. At some time I need to go thru Hansard for 1855 but life has taken for the moment.

  5. Dr N Says:

    Obviously you have not researched your chosen scape goat very thoroughly at all. Have you even tried this method of treatment, or are you simply using information that you assume is correct because this suits your opinion? Why don’t you contact the Royal London Homeopathic Hospital, or maybe some homeopathic vets who have amazing success with homeopathy and animals (doesn’t this suggest that the placaebo myth may in fact be wrong!).
    Your complete lack of knowledge in this subject would suggest that it may benefit you, and others, to research this subject more thoroughly before ridiculing something you know nothing about.

  6. jaycueaitch Says:

    Why is it ‘obvious’? Other than the fact that I disagree with you that is. Please state where in the above post you think I am wrong.

    Btw I have not used homeopathy. So what? I have not swallowed potassium cyanide but I still know it to be a deadly toxin from my knowledge of chemistry and I would say so if the subject came up.

    Btw 2. A scapegoat (one word) is something that is blamed for society’s ills. In what way is the above post scapegoating homeopathy?

  7. Dr N Says:

    Goodness me, you are so desperately short sighted that you are overlooking a whole system of health simply because you do not understand it. All of your statements are wrong, the fact that you do not know that is proof that you have not researched homeopathy.
    Btw – picking up on a typo is a little bit OTT, don’t you think?
    Maybe you should find something a little more productive to do with your time, I certainly will.
    Best wishes

  8. jaycueaitch Says:

    I have researched homeopathy and found what it is about. That is why I oppose it. I am afraid that the fact that I disagree with you is not proof that I do not understand it. If I am wrong, please explain where. Put up or shut up. Your choice.

  9. A Second Year of Steam « Letting Off Steam Says:

    [...] two three four five six seven [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 162 other followers

%d bloggers like this: