Say Goodbye to Your Liberty

The front page headline of today’s Guardian:

Government wants personal details of every traveller

“Passengers travelling between EU countries or taking domestic flights would have to hand over a mass of personal information, including their mobile phone number and credit card details, as part of a new package of security measures being demanded by the British government. The data would be stored for 13 years and used to “profile” suspects.”

The data is the same as demanded by the Department of Homeland Security for flights between Europe and the US. Brussels officials are already proposing collecting the same information on every air passenger entering or leaving the EU but Britain wants the system extended to sea and rail travel, domestic flights and those between EU countries. Furthermore, the British Government wants the system to be used for “more general public policy purposes” besides fighting terrorism and organised crime.

We are not told what these purposes are and how they will be helped by collecting such important personal data.

As regards fighting terrorism, which is the governments stock excuse for all their assaults on civil liberty, how is it going to work? I presume the idea is that if someone has been buying products that could be used to make a bomb (fertiliser, flour, peroxide, timers –  ie all kinds of innocent purchases) they will get a special going over by the security services. If their mobile phone records show them as contacting numbers already considered dodgy by the Security Services, this will also attract attention.

The obvious problem is who is considered dodgy? We are led to assume Islamic fundementalists but in the past Special Branch have considered CND acivists, Trade Unionists and Labour Party members to fit the bill of potential subversives. According to Michael Moore, the Deparment of Homeland Security has put members of the American Green Party on its no-fly list.

In any event it seems to be that it will be easy for genuine terrorists to avoid this surveillance:-

1. Travel by private car wherever possible.

2. Have two credit cards and two mobile phones, one of each to be used for terrorist purposes and the other kept for innocent purposes. When travelling, offer up the details of the innocent card and phone.

So this government crap will not prevent terrorist atrocities. What it will do is store lots of personal information that will be highly useful to fraudsters and identity thieves. Remember the loss of personal details of millions of families receiving child benefit? I think it can be safely said that there will be many more such data losses, while terrorists remain free to go about their ghastly business because the police are too busy reading through the credit card purchases of innocent people.

Meanwhile, the conviction of Mark Dixie for the murder of Sally Anne Bowman and Steve Wright for the murder of Tania Nicol, Gemma Adams, Anneli Alderton, Annette Nicholls and Paula Clennell has predicatably fuelled demands for a national DNA register since both convictions were based on DNA evidence.

This sounds like a no-brainer but DNA evidence is not the magic bullet it is made out to be. We all shed DNA all the time in the form of hair and skin flakes. Someone sitting on the train seat you have just vacated will pick up some of your DNA from it. If he goes to to commit a crime, he could leave some of your DNA there as well as his own. Or a crime could be commited somewhere you have passed through previously. Your DNA will be picked up by the Scene of Crime Officers. As far as they are concerned, you were at the crime scene and it will be up to you to prove you were not.

Both of these measures move the burden of proof from prosecution to defense – guilt is assumed unless the accused can prove otherwise. We are in danger of giving up our liberty to purchase safety and as Thomas Jefferson pointed out 230 years ago, if we do that we will have neither.


Tags: , , , ,

6 Responses to “Say Goodbye to Your Liberty”

  1. gimpy Says:

    Scary isn’t it? Here is a quote from a Scottish MSP on a compulsory DNA database from The Scotsman.

    Paul Martin, MSP, Scottish Labour’s community safety spokesman, said “model citizens” would have nothing to fear from having their DNA held on a national database and he called for a debate on the issue.

    These people are halfwits and they are in charge.

  2. Ray C. Says:

    First, I wouldn’t say quite all the infringements on civil liberties arise from the War on Terra. The War On Some Drugs is the reason I have to sign my name and address over to the jackboots just to get a cold pill with pseudoephredine in it.

    Second, that quote about liberty and safety came from Benjamin Franklin. Though I suppose Jefferson would have agreed.

  3. gimpy Says:

    The comment above mine is spam.

  4. jaycueaitch Says:

    Cheers gimpy, deleted.

    Fair points Ray. Maybe I’ll just attribute further such statements to “A Founding Father of the US”

  5. HJ Says:

    Good post, certainly interesting to think about..

  6. emily Says:

    Unless it is compulsary these days to have a mobile they could always not take it, methinks. I still [shock horror] don;t even have one. Would that make me suspicious?

    Anything used for profiling is best avoided. The profiling boffins aren’t half as good as they like to think they are. Most have never quite come to grips with the causality error (a is often/always b not meaning b is often/always a).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: