The Blame Game

Once again computer games are being blamed for violence, the impetus this time being the release of Grand Theft Auto IV.

The evidence presented is anecdotal – someone was mugged after purchasing the game and there were fights in the queue to buy the game.

In the case of the mugging it was the victimnot the robber who owned the game. The desire of anti-social thugs to own the game at someone else’s expense is not evidence that there is anything wrong with the game. Using that logic we should also ban mobile phones, credit cards and money. The fights in the queue prove nothing either. When a new IKEA store opened not so long ago there was a riot as bargain-hunters fought with one another to get their hands on the opening night special offers. I don’t recall this leading to any calls for IKEA to be closed down to prevent public disorder.

If anecdotal evidence counts, then here is mine:-

I do not own any of the Grand Theft Auto games but I did play “Doom” a lot in the Nineties (incidently, if anyone has a PlayStation version of Doom they would like to sell, please email me). I have yet to go on a gun rampage shooting anything that crosses my path. I enjoy playing Gran Turismo and other games that involve driving at speed. Not only do I not speed in real life, I don’t drive at all.

I could go on but I think I have made my point; you can find anecdotal evidence to support any position you wish to take. The proposition that there is a link between such games and anti-social behaviour is worth examining however, though perhaps it should be undertaken by a university’s social science department rather than by tabloid journalists with space to fill and a deadline to meet.

Tags: , , ,

5 Responses to “The Blame Game”

  1. Andrew Says:

    Presumably the theory is that the queue, and ergo the crime, would have not happened had the game not existed. Therefore the game caused the crime.

    So we should ban people from being in places.

  2. dvnutrix Says:

    I played Lemmings. I have yet to walk off a cliff or spontaneously self-detonate. I do occasionally say, “Oh No!!!” but only ever in the presence of others whom I know to have played the game.

  3. jdc Says:

    I played Championship Manager and I have yet to win a European Cup or receive a bung from a transfer fee. Gutted.

    By the way, I would like to be the first to call for IKEA to be closed down to prevent public disorder. Then we can move onto banning credit cards, money and mobile phones. I’ll have us back in the dark ages in a jiffy. Along with the homeopaths and anti-vaccinators.

  4. Danny Says:

  5. gimpy Says:

    I played Half Life and did not become a physicist nor fight of alien invasion. However, I did play Sim Life and became a biologist with skills in genetic engineering.

Leave a Reply to Andrew Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: