Reasons Why Nadine Dorries Pisses Me Off

I’m getting sick of Nadine Dorries MP. Here’s why:-

1. She’s devious. Okay, so she’s an MP and two-faced underhandedness is their stock in trade but she seems particularly bad. She has tabled an amendment to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill that would bring the upper limit for pregnancy terminations down from 24 to 20 weeks.

Fair enough if that’s what she believes it should be. I disagree but in a democracy such things are debated, preferably with each side supporting their views with evidence. However, in a comment following this Spectator article, she says:-

“I do want to go lower than twenty weeks – I would settle for the European average of thirteen weeks but would prefer nine,”

So why did she not put nine weeks as an upper limit in her amendment instead of twenty? Because she knew it would be defeated. You can guarantee that if she succeeds with this amendment she will be back in a couple of years demanding a reduction to eighteen or sixteen weeks.

 2. She’s intellectually dishonest. She uses emotive claims of fetus viability to support the reduction to twenty weeks. I presume even she will admit that fetuses are not viable at twenty weeks, yet she is on record as wanting to reduce the limit to nine weeks. Clearly she does not really believe her own viability argument. Hardly surprising that she does not. Of pregnancies miscarried at 23 weeks fewer than one in ten ever leave hospital and many are severely impaired. So not really viable then.

3. She’s a liar. Kira Cochrane, in her article  “The End of Choice?” in today’s Guardian g2, points out to Dorries that the British Medical Association, among other organisations, supports the current limit. This apparantly provoked a rant from Dorries in which she claimed that doctors were not given a proper chance to vote for a reduction.

Cochrane contacted the BMA who quoted the following motion from their 2005 conference:-

“This meeting holds that the upper limit for legal abortion should be reduced in the light of new evidence of foetal development and advances in neonatal care.”

The motion was rejected. So the BMA are in fact following their members wishes. I wonder if Dories has consulted her constituents as to their views?

4. She seems to be afraid of debate. She puts contentious views on her blog but does not allow comments. I wonder why?

5. She’s either a hypocrite or colossally ignorant. She professes not to know what feminism is and implies that feminism has not achieved anything. It does not seem to occur to her that if it was not for feminism, she would be ignored. Of course, it was feminists in the 1960s who successfully lobbied for abortion to be legalised. This might explain Dorries’ attitude.

Tags: , , , ,

4 Responses to “Reasons Why Nadine Dorries Pisses Me Off”

  1. dvnutrix Says:

    I would hope that between you and Hawk/Handsaw plus other coverage, Dorries’ views and distortions of the relevant research and other pertinent matters are getting a good airing.

  2. wilsontown Says:

    Dorries does seem to be an extraordinary piece of work. I wasn’t really aware of her until I saw her quoted in the Guardian, rubbishing a piece of peer-reviewed research in the BMJ because it disagreed with her pre-conceptions. Since then, she seems to have hardly put pen to paper without misrepresenting the evidence on survival rates of extremely premature infants. And all of this after she accused Ben Goldacre of leaking publicly available documents.

    Generally I think that MPs are more decent and honourable than they get credit for, but Dorries is certainly not. Her behaviour over the Human Fertilisation and Embryology bill has been nothing short of disgraceful.

  3. jdc325 Says:

    Nice one JQH – I’ve been reading about Dorries on quite a few blogs recently. Ministry of Truth has had some good stuff. has three excellent recent posts on Dorries and Bad Science and Pyjamas in Bananas had some cracking pieces up last October (around the time of the Minority Report).

  4. Apathy Sketchpad » Blog Archive » A lengthy political rant. I won’t be cross if you don’t read it. Says:

    […] particularly done wrong — and the Conservatives aren’t better. The Conservatives think anti-science nonsense-fountain Nadine Dorries is a viable MP. Ann Widdecombe, an insane, shouty, far-right lunatic who supported The Master for […]

Leave a Reply to dvnutrix Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: