[BPSDB]I’ve been reading Ofquack’s criteria for professional registration of CAM practitioners here, after Deano on the Bad Science forum pointed out some of the inanities to be found therein. It’s quite scary that this sort of stuff is receiving Establishment backing but as Private Eye and others have pointed out, Charles Windsor has been pushing strongly for this. Consider the Windsors’ favourite CAM, homeopathy, for example.
In the Introduction to the Homeopathy Dec08 pdf we find:-
“Homeopathy is a holistic system of healing…based on … treating “like with like”. Homeopathic medicines are diluted natural substances that if given to a healthy person, over time, would produce the symptoms for which the medicine is prescribed”
Homeopathic medicines are mot merely diluted, they are serially diluted to such an extent that the last molecule of active ingredient must have been thrown down the drain. All you are left with is plain water or a sugar pill onto which said plain water has been placed and allowed to evaporate. Note that despite the claims to be holistic it is concerned purely with the symptoms of the patient.
In “Knowledge and Understanding” We find:-
“3.10 homeopathic concepts of health, disease and progress in treatment”
Homeopaths reject the germ theory of disease so it would appear that the requirements for professional registration include a rejection of evidence based medicine. For them treatment consists of trying to make the symptoms go away and if this happens (or the patient and practitioner are convinced it has happened), declaring the patient “cured”. This is holistic, apparantly.
In “Homeopathic Evaluation” we find the practitioner must be aware of:-
“symptoms suggestive of miasmatic influence”.
“Miasms” are the mystic fogs that homeopaths invoke to explain the transmission of disease. In other words, magic is being endorsed as a suitable medical therapy in the twentyfirst century.
Under prognosis the practitioner must be aware of:-
“individual motivation and commitment to treatment” and
“the individual’s family and their resistance to any change”
In other words, if the patients do not get better, blame them or their families.
Under “Treatment Planning” the “Vital Force” is mentioned. More magical thinking.
“Advising clients on the effects oh homeopathic medicines” contains the classic
“a) initial intensification of existing symptoms (aggravations)
“b) return of old symptoms
“c) development of different symptoms”
This is where homeopaths proclaim the progression of a disease as proof the remedy is working!
The above are just sample quotes but frankly the document could use a line by line fisking. Skills for Health are in effect endorsing magical thinking and giving it the Establishment stamp of approval.